Ask the corner

Questions & Answers

Ask about the sources, the arguments, or the history. I answer the good ones here.

F
Is "Hamar" really from the Arabic for red, or is that a later story?
Faadumo · 3 days ago
Khalid replies

Later rationalisation, in my reading. The Somali plant name geed-xamar predates the colour story — full argument is in the etymology article and the research notes.

▲ 24Reply
C
Why do you reject Lewis's "Arab colonisation" framing so strongly?
Cabdi · 5 days ago
Khalid replies

Because the genealogies and shared ritual vocabulary show exchange in both directions. "Colonisation" pre-decides that culture only moved one way. The evidence doesn't.

▲ 41Reply
H
Where can I start with the Walasma dynasty if I'm new to it?
Hodan · 1 week ago
▲ 12Reply